Best Tasting Icing for Cookies

Hello folks…
I’m planning to ice some cookies and want them to not only look great but taste delicious as well. I’m leaning towards decorative designs with different colors, but I’m a bit unsure about the best type of icing to use.

I’ve heard that royal icing is commonly used for decorating cookies, but it seems like it might taste terrible and end up crunchy. On the other hand, buttercream icing is often recommended for its taste, but I’m concerned it might be difficult to work with for delicate designs.

Hey cooks,
Even though royal icing is primarily used for decoration, it may also be very sweet. Though it might not have the greatest flavor, it works well for intricate drawings.
Simple ingredients for sugar cookie icing are powdered sugar, milk, and vanilla. It is adaptable and simple to alter in terms of taste and color.
Rich and velvety, buttercream icing is a favorite for a lot of cookies. It can be prepared using several kinds of shortening or butter.

1 Like

Are you going to pack them into individual bags or anything similar, or do you need them to stack neatly? If so, your greatest chance of keeping a sophisticated design intact is to use royal icing. Although taste is obviously subjective, I agree that it doesn’t taste nice, but it’s a fantastic medium for artistic expression.

1 Like

Use of American buttercream will result in a thin crust, but it won’t be as solid as with royal icing.

So, the question is, what kind of look or style are you going for? You can always add vanilla or almond extract to your royal icing.

Use cookies with real flavor, not just plain vanilla. Royal icing is the only type that dries firm enough to stack cookies or pack them in multiple rows (I still recommend using baking paper between layers). You can add flavors to the royal icing lemon and almond essences are the most common. Lemon juice works too, but essence provides a stronger flavor. Other flavor essences are also available, like strawberry, and some novelty options such as bubblegum. Just ensure that any essences with colors are colorless if you want to avoid adding color to your icing.